Carruth Trial: The Defense Strategizes
C H A R L O T T E, N.C., Dec. 11 -- Lawyers for former NFL player Rae Carruthbegan his defense against a murder charge today by trying to chipaway at the credibility of a witness who said Carruth mastermindedthe slaying of his girlfriend.
Prosecutors had ended their case earlier today after 12 days oftestimony that included more than two dozen witnesses.
Carruth is charged with engineering the slaying of ChericaAdams, who was eight months pregnant with Carruth’s son when she was shot on Nov. 16, 1999. The baby survived, but Adams died amonth later.
The prosecution argued that Carruth had Adams killed because hedidn’t want to pay child support. Defense lawyers say the shooting happened because Carruth refused to finance a proposed drug deal.
Key Witness Testimony Questioned
The first defense witness, former prosecutor Thomas C. Porter,testified that key prosecution witness Michael Kennedy wasn’ttelling the truth when he told the jury about a previous assaultcharge against him.
Kennedy, a co-defendant of Carruth, had said the charge againsthim was dropped because a videotape showed he wasn’t involved in the wounding of another man in a drug deal.
However, Porter, who prosecuted Kennedy in that case but is nowa defense lawyer, said Kennedy wasn’t prosecuted because a witness couldn’t be located.
In surprise testimony against Carruth, made without a plea dealand against the wishes of his own lawyers, Kennedy had told jurorsCarruth recruited him to be the driver in the attack and paid him$100 to buy the gun used in the shooting.
After Kennedy’s testimony, prosecutors decided not to callconfessed triggerman Van Brett Watkins. He pleaded guilty tosecond-degree murder in July and agreed to testify against Carruth.Now Watkins may appear only if the defense calls him.
Some of the most damaging prosecution testimony came from Adams’ own voice on a 911 tape, played for jurors Nov. 20.
“He (Carruth) was in the car in front of me, and he slowed downand somebody pulled up beside me and did this,” Adams told the 911 dispatcher after she was shot.



