Rethinking the Rules of Parenting

April 14, 2003 — -- Any parent knows how frustrating it can be when children just don't listen: when they refuse to get dressed, or throw a tantrum when told it's time for bed.

But parenting instructor Mac Bledsoe has a radical idea: disobedience is not always bad. He believes it can be turned around to teach a child to think for himself.

"Obedience as a tool for discipline is really, really dangerous," Bledsoe told 20/20's John Stossel. "It does not teach children to think for themselves, and it teaches them to listen to an outside voice to find out how to act."

Bledsoe believes parents should aim to teach their children how to make decisions for themselves, so they can act responsibly when left alone, and become more independent when they get older.

Watching With Hidden Cameras

Like other parents before them, Kristin and Joe Marquez believed that obedience is a crucial value to instill in a child. So when their 5-year-old, Joseph, would act up by refusing to take a bath or go to bed, they would insist, provoking long tantrums.

They tried timeouts and mild spanking, but nothing worked. When they spoke to 20/20, they were getting desperate, and beginning to doubt whether they were good parents.

"Every other word out of my mouth is, 'Don't do that, stop doing that, play nice.' It's always something negative," Kristin said.

The couple, who both work full-time, allowed 20/20 to place hidden cameras in their home. The cameras caught some of their frustration, with Joe at one point telling his son, "God darn it. Why is it so hard for you to do what I ask?"

Making Their Own Choices

20/20 introduced the Marquezes to Mac Bledsoe, who tours the country giving parenting seminars. Bledsoe does not have a degree in child psychology, but says he has expertise in parenting from 29 years of teaching and coaching high school football. He is also a parent himself, with two successful sons, one who is starting a business and another, Drew Bledsoe, a quarterback for the Buffalo Bills. Bledsoe has a new book based on his video series, "Parenting with Dignity," and a Web site sponsored by his football-playing son's foundation.

After talking to the Marquezes and watching tapes of them interacting with Joseph and his 3-year-old sister, Victoria, Bledsoe had some advice.

First, he said, the Marquezes should allow Joseph to make some of his own decisions, easy ones where safety is not an issue. "Let him choose and experience the consequences," Bledsoe said.

As an example, one hot summer's day Joseph had wanted to wear long pants, but his mother told him to wear shorts. Bledsoe suggested that next time she try letting Joseph have his own way. Perhaps he would be sweaty in long pants, he said, but he'd learn from his own mistake.

Focusing on the Positive

Another strategy Bledsoe suggested was for the Marquezes to focus on what they wanted Joseph to do, rather than tell him what he should not do. "If you tell someone, 'don't think about elephants,' it's elephants that they'll think about," he said.

In the supermarket, when Joseph wanted a toy, his mother had told him, "You're not getting a toy, Joe. I'm telling you right now." But once she told Joseph he could not have a toy, all of the boy's thoughts were focused on the toy, Bledsoe said. He suggested she shift his attention by saying instead: "That's a cool toy. Let's put it back and go find the popcorn" — replacing the image in his head of getting a toy with the image of finding the popcorn.

Acknowleding that there are times when a child must obey, Bledsoe said parents should give clear instructions and, if the child does not obey, let him feel the consequences.

Practice Sessions

Another strategy Bledsoe suggested is practice sessions: "rehearsing" a problematic process ahead of time, so parents and children can go over away from the anger or frustration of the moment. He suggested the Marquezes sit the children down one day before dinnertime and say, "OK, kids, tonight we're going to practice — before we have dinner, we're going to practice appropriate dinner behavior."

To avert Joseph's dressing tantrums, Bledsoe advised Joe to have a session with his son the night before, and to pick out what he would wear the next day.

Learning For Themselves

Bledsoe said the aim should always be to teach children to think for themselves, so that when they are away from their parents, they can make the right decisions.

Bledsoe said that the willfulness and independence in a child like Joseph could actually pay dividends later — for instance, he might be more likely to resist peer pressure to use drugs when he becomes a teenager.

Seeing an Improvement

After the Marquezes met Bledsoe, they started putting his advice into action, allowing Joseph to make more of his own decisions, and telling him what they wanted him to do instead of always saying no. Two months later, they said, they found parenting less of a struggle and more of a pleasure.

Kristin said trips to the grocery store have actually become fun after she took Bledsoe's advice to involve the children in the process, like letting Joseph make the grocery list.

Joe and Joseph have practiced the dressing routine the night before and have seen an improvement. "There's no arguments in the morning about what he's going to wear because he's involved in picking it out," Joe said.

Now, 14 months later, Kristin says Joseph is doing better than ever. "His teacher has even commented on it," she said, "and best of all, I have my husband back, now that the stress is down."

You can learn more about Mac Bledsoe's parenting techniques at www.parentingwithdignity.com

This Report Was Originally Broadcast Feb. 1, 2002.