20/20: Beware the Car Dealer's Secret

Oct. 27, 2000 -- On today’s 20/20, Arnold Diaz warns car buyers about the hidden charges car dealers may tack on during the purchase of a car.

According to consumer attorney Gary Klein, “It’s a dirty little secret that the auto lending industry has not owned up to.”

It works like this. Car dealers do not do the actual money lending, but send your application to a number of lenders, who then tell them what interest rate you qualify for. They call that number the “buy rate.” But legally, car dealers are not required to tell you that rate or how much they are marking up the loan. Dealers get a small fee for arranging loans at the buy rate, but can make a lot more money if they can get you to pay a higher rate. And lenders encourage that because they usually split the extra income.

David Robertson, head of the Association of Finance and Insurance Professionals — a trade group representing finance managers — defends the practice, saying it’s akin to a retail markup on loans. “The dealership provides a valuable service on behalf of the customer in negotiating these loans,” he says. “Because of that, the dealership should be compensated for that work.”

And there’s troubling evidence that black customers may be twice as likely as whites to have their rate marked up — and by more. That evidence — included in thousands of pages of confidential documents that 20/20 and The New York Times went into a Tennessee court to obtain — shows that Nissan and GM dealers in that state routinely marked up rates for blacks, forcing them to pay between $300 and $400 more than whites.

“The bottom line is that everyone who pays markup is affected by markup and is the victim of a secret policy, but blacks are victimized worse,” says Klein, a lawyer with the National Consumer Law Center (www.nclc.org) who is working on a discrimination lawsuit against GM Acceptance Corporation and Nissan Motors Acceptance Corporation.

The legal team in the discrimination suit filed against the two companies had an expert analyze thousands of confidential customer files from Tennessee Nissan and GM dealers and say they reveal a pattern of discrimination. In Nissan’s case, white customers loans were marked up an average of $507 — but black customers faced a $969 markup. At the GM dealers, blacks paid $315 more in markup than whites.In statements, both companies say this analysis is “seriously flawed” and point out that their loan application does not ask the buyer’s race. Both the companies and the dealers insist they do no tolerate any racial discrimination.

Prep Before You ShopSo how do you ensure you’re not paying more than you should? Before you approach a dealer, get online and compare rates. You can find some Web links on the right. BanxQuote (www.banx.com) and Bankrate.com (www.bankrate.com) provide various lenders’ rates for new and used car loans.

You can apply online for a loan through LendingTree.com (www.lendingtree.com). Plug in your salary and preferred payment structure, and LendingTree will return three to four different rates, giving you more information to bargain with dealers, or sidestep them completely.

And for a $3.95/monthly fee, Consumer Reports Online (www.ConsumerReports.org) can be a valuable tool for car buyers. The site contains information on more than 200 car models, including test results, ratings and survey results about vehicle reliability and driver satisfaction. Edmunds.com (www.edmunds.com) is another choice for car facts and pricing on new and used models. Finally, the Kelley Blue Book (www.kbb.com) will tell you how much your current car is worth, a valuable tool when considering a trade-in.