The Pluck of the Irish
Ireland battles economic woes, offering lessons for America.
March 17, 2010 -- As Irish Americans mark St. Patrick's Day with bagpipes, parades and profound displays of drunkenness, mother Ireland finds herself suffering from one nasty economic hangover.
Irish financial institutions, not unlike those in the United States, overindulged during the past decade, lending hand over fist in a bubbly real estate market and leveraging balance sheets to the hilt. And like those in the United States, Irish banks, most dramatically Anglo Irish Bank, needed government assistance after the party ended.
Unlike their American counterparts, however, Irish bankers, political leaders and citizens have, for the most part, come together to do whatever was necessary to climb back up off the floor, including across-the-board spending cuts.
Ireland, fittingly, is starting to see some green shoots.
"We've still got a long way to go, but I think some of the hardest belt-tightening decisions have been made," Dublin City University finance professor Brian O'Kelly said. "People here are optimistic that we've turned a corner."
The optimism is shared by Kevin Gardiner, the Barclays analyst who is credited with coining, in 1994, the famous "Celtic Tiger" moniker for the Irish economy.
Speaking at an investor conference last month in Dublin, Gardiner said Ireland's debt-burdened economy is stabilizing and may return to growth in the second half of 2010, according to a Bloomberg News report.
"Slowly, [Ireland] is starting to stabilize," Gardiner said. "Having seen a huge fall, maybe [it] will see a period of stability in 2010 and some growth in the second half."
Swift, tough decisions, such as the slashing of pay for Irish civil servants, have drawn accolades from financial markets and European leaders facing similar financial straits, the Wall Street Journal recently reported.
"Sure, the unions grumbled," O'Kelly said. "But people here sort of collectively realized that it had to be done and that to get through this period we all needed to work together."
The Irish economy roared for the better part of the past two decades, a darling developing market fuelled by a technology and pharmaceutical boom in the 1990s. Ireland's unemployment, historically double digit, fell, at one point, to as low as 4 percent.
The expanding economy produced a new generation of wealthy citizens, a phenomenon that subsequently gave way to a real estate boom, which, in turn, attracted hot money from more developed European investors looking for growth opportunity and higher yields.
But following its own real estate and credit crisis -- two "rogue" banks in particular, Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide, wrote down tens of billions of Euros in bad loans -- Ireland has a new economic moniker, one it shares with its fiscally challenged European neighbors to the south.
Ireland, along with Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain, is now seen as being part of the European "PIIGS" sovereign debt crisis that threatens to plunge the European Union into recession.
"Ireland's growth was fuelled by unprecedented debt," said Irish-born money management executive Ciaran Spillane, who is head of U.K.-based Newton Capital Management's North American business. "Now comes the deleveraging period, which probably means a protracted recovery."
"When the U.S. credit markets completely locked up in 2008 after Lehman collapsed, it was like an earthquake that shook the entire world," said Gregory Connor, a finance professor at the National University of Ireland, Maynooth, in County Kildare. "The economies with the worst foundations sustained the most damage. Ireland was overleveraged."
Ireland's real estate and construction industries, which by 2005-06 had replaced the technology sector as a means for bankers and investors to ride the Celtic Tiger, came to a screeching halt in 2008, ending a boom during which Ireland's economy, as measured by gross domestic product, doubled over the course of the decade.
Irish Economy Shrank Most in Europe in 2009
Ireland's economy shrank 7.5 percent in 2009, the most of any European nation.
Professors Connor and O'Kelly, along with a third Irish academic, Thomas Flavin, recently coauthored a research paper examining the Irish financial crisis. While in some ways there are some comparisons to be made to the U.S. crisis -- cheap money and banks using too much leverage -- the authors were able to point to a number of significant differences, such as the absence of a supercharged loan securitization market exacerbating an already dangerous situation.
In the aftermath of the crisis, Ireland's Finance Minister Brian Lenihan moved quickly to establish a TARP-like entity, the National Asset Management Agency.
"In recent months the Irish government have been seen as doing a credible job in responding to the crisis despite past mistakes," Spillane said. "Three or four months ago, Ireland was in the position that Greece is in now, but today global investors appear to have taken the view that the Irish government is taking many of the painful policy measures necessary to restore fiscal health."
The agency used government bonds to buy property loans at a discount from banks, which will then be able to cash the bonds with the European Central Bank. This took toxic assets off the bank's balance sheets, as opposed to the thrust of the TARP's first phase, which directly injected banks with capital and, in many cases, left toxic assets on their balance sheets.
One other stark difference in the aftermath of the crisis, Connor said, was the political will of Irish leaders and citizens who for the most part understood and supported the concept of shared sacrifice.
"Because we are part of the EU and don't control our own currency, Ireland's financial situation is more comparable to the problems encountered by individual U.S. states," Connor said. "But the bottom line is, spending and borrowing had to be cut."
"The government even made cuts to social welfare, which in Ireland was long thought to be unthinkable," O'Kelly said.
With a history of economic hardship stretching back centuries and more modern malaise lasting well into the 1980s, Ireland's workforce had only relatively recently tasted the kind of prosperity America has known on and off for the better part of the past century.
A much needed attitude readjustment was in order, O'Kelly said.
"I grew up in an era where deferred gratification was advocated," he said. "The Celtic Tiger cubs learned to spend ostentatiously 'because they were worth it,' but the cubs must rediscover old-fashioned values."
Doubts About Irish Recovery
Not everybody is seeing green shoots in Ireland, however. Standard & Poor's analysts in December, affirming an AA long-term credit rating (the second best possible rating) issued a report that said: "the potential for further increases in the already substantial general government debt burden due to the continued fragility in the Irish banking sector, and weaker-than-expected outturns in the public finances due to the ongoing recession, have led us to maintain the negative outlook."
The Irish Ministry for Finance, meanwhile, earlier this month released a statement pointing out data that showed that while the number of householders who were in arrears on mortgage payments had increased in December, the rate of increase continued to slow down. The figures showed 3.6 percent of Irish mortgage accounts in arrears in December, compared with 3.3 percent in September.
These figures, combined with the figures for the covered institutions from earlier in 2009 confirm an easing in the rate of increase in mortgage defaults.