Cher Goes Online for Not Commercial
November 7, 2000 -- Recorded on a shoestring budget while she was between record deals in 1994, Cher's Internet-only release this week of Not Commercial marks yet another curious turn in her disparate musical career.
Not quite rock, pop, or folk, even Cher isn't sure how to categorize it.
"I don't know what it is. You heard it. What kind of music is it?" she asked in an interview with Wall of Sound. "I'm not even sure it's any good.
"But I do think it will be meaningful to a few people," she said of the long-shelved CD, which she kept in "a little safe" at home for six years. "It's like some strange hybrid of music. Like stories sung to you."
Full of blunt language and personal confessions, Not Com is Cher's first attempt at full-fledged songwriting after decades of encouraging a long line of producers, lovers, and friends to shape her sound. She wrote it after attending a songwriters' conference on a whim.
"I wasn't going to do anything with it," she said of the record. "I was just going to have the experience. I've always written poetry, scribbled little things, little song pieces. Once I committed to this, I just couldn't stop writing."
Among her topics: Her troubled childhood, the Catholic Church, the homeless, the suicide of Kurt Cobain, and a tormented relationship with a married man, which she chronicles on the bitter ballad "Still."
"It was brief and really intense," she said of the romance, which occurred several years ago and somehow escaped the tabloids. "No one I know saw what I saw in him. His wife even called me once and said, 'What do you see in my husband?' and I went, 'Well, if you don't know, I can't tell you.'"
On "The Fall," about the suicide of alt-pioneer Cobain (whom she did not know), she writes of the distinct pressures of iconic stardom: "Was there no one who could rescue you from the prison of your pain?/ Am I tougher or just lucky my fate didn't end the same."
She saves her most intense anger for "Sisters of Mercy," an indictment of Catholicism and the nuns who cared for her when her mother was enduring some difficulties. In the song she calls the church "cruel, heartless, and wicked" for locking her away, long after her mother attempted to retrieve her. (Church leaders have already issued the standard denouncements.)
When Cher brought the completed record to former Warner U.K. chief Rob Dickens six years ago, he wasn't moved, dubbing it "nice, but not commercial." Taking the rejection in stride, Cher went on to make some of the best music of her career with Warners: 1995's It's a Man's World and 1998's Believe, the label's top-seller of 1999. Next year she'll be back on Warner U.K. again with what she's dubbed Son of Believe, another powerhouse dance set she's preparing now.
As for the unsold demo, she made a few copies for the guys in Paul Shaffer's Late Show band, who had helped her record it, and passed a few out as Christmas gifts before putting it away and pretty much forgetting about it.
It wasn't until a friend suggested she could sell it independently at her own Web site, cher.com, that she thought about letting fans hear it — though she warns, "It's not for kids.
"I don't see this as being a very big album. I won't be playing it anywhere," she says of the record's limited PR campaign. "I was listening to it the other day and I thought this stuff is just so personal, is anyone gonna give a s--t?"
Apparently so. Advance orders for Not Com have exceeded the expectations of ArtistDirect, the online marketing company helping her ship CDs to fans. She's aware that the industry may be watching this experiment. If she sells a lot of records, she may prove that established stars with loyal followings may not always need the old-fashioned middle-man system that the major record labels provide — though that is not her intent.
"I really don't know much about the politics of it," Cher says. "I just knew there was no place for this album, except the Internet."
Still, she is among very few stars to release an independent CD while in the midst of an active recording contract with a major label. Though Warner Bros. has had no comment on Not Com and may be wishing Cher would go away until PR time for the Believe follow-up, the label did grant her permission to do this, she says.
"I even got the title from them," she says, recalling the day her friend Dickens rejected her. "The Internet is so unbelievable in this case because people who don't want to be bothered by [this record] won't even have to know it's around."
Though raw in places, she made only a modest effort to spruce up the recording before releasing it. "This album is not about perfection. If it was, I would have re-recorded the whole thing and gotten someone to really arrange it properly. It's rough. It's just demo quality, really."