Latest Fashion Trend: Eyeball Jewelry?
August 10, 2004 -- Ridiculous. Weird. Strange. These are the adjectives some ophthalmologists are using to describe eyeball jewelry — a new kind of body adornment imported from Europe and now being showcased on American shores.
That's right. If you want to add glitz to your gaze, you can have a thin platinum jewel implanted in the mucus membrane of the eye. And to do it, you don't have to go all the way to Europe, where the procedure originated. You just have to go to L.A.
Robert K. Maloney, director of Maloney Vision Institute in Los Angeles, is the first ophthalmologist in America to perform the procedure.
Unlike many of his colleagues, Maloney thinks that eyeball jewelry is fun — and safe.
"We believe it's as safe as wearing contact lenses. It's certainly as safe as the colored contact lenses you see all the time — it may be safer — and it's really a lot of fun," says Maloney. "It's a really neat way to make yourself unique if that's something you want to do."
But many ophthalmologists are wary of eyeball jewelry, and are issuing strong cautions about the fashion trend.
"I am not in favor of this type of surgery because there may be risks such as chronic eye redness, irritation, and even infection," says Allan Rutzen, associate professor of ophthalmology at the University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore. "The general population needs to know that this has not been thoroughly tested and that the risks are not fully known."
Warns Jim McCulley, professor and chairman, Department of Ophthalmology at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas, "They are taking unknown risks that might be vision threatening."
The Procedure
To give his customers a twinkle in their eye, Maloney implants a 0.13-inch wide piece of jewelry into the conjunctiva — the mucus membrane lining the front of the eyeball.
"The eye is covered by a thin layer of skin and we make a small incision in that skin and slip the jewel underneath," says Maloney. "It sits on top of the eyeball itself."
The 15-minute procedure costs $3,900 and is performed under local anesthetic.
The procedure was developed and patented by The Rotterdam Institute in the Netherlands. There have been no reported side effects or complications in the approximately 50 people around the world who have opted for eyeball jewels.
And according to Maloney, the procedure is painless.
"As you recover, there's some mild irritation for a couple of weeks and there's some redness around the jewel and all the redness goes away and the discomfort goes away and you've got a little twinkle in your eye."
Maloney's first customer chose a heart as her eyeball jewel. And the 21-year-old woman is delighted with the new twinkle in her eye.
"One of the really neat things about it — it's not obvious from the picture — it's much more subtle than it looks," says Maloney. "When you're looking at people straight ahead you don't see it. It's when they look to the side that you can suddenly see the jewel.
Maloney predicts that this is what many of his future customers will find appealing about eyeball jewelry.
"There's this sense of it being a secret. Something that's uncovered, something to be revealed," says Maloney.
Is It Really Safe?
But the American Academy of Ophthalmology released a statement in April expressing concern and cautions about the procedure. And eyeball jewelry or "JewelEye" has not yet been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, or FDA.
After briefly reviewing Maloney's press release on eye jewelry, the FDA released a statement saying although it needs more information to proceed, the agency would not regulate the eye jewelry as a medical device, but perhaps as a cosmetic.
Maloney, after talking with a lawyer, doesn't believe eye jewelry needs to be regulated by the FDA at all.
"I don't believe the FDA has regulatory authority — they may claim regulatory authority, in which case we can do an FDA trial."
Yet even Maloney cautions the procedure has to be performed by a licensed ophthalmic surgeon.
"We've been putting implants under the eye for a very long time, for maybe 30 to 40 years," says Maloney. "Even though this is brand new, the general concept of an implant is something that is tried and true."
‘ Way Out of Mainstream Medicine’
But other ophthalmologists maintain eyeball jewelry procedures are unnecessary and unsafe.
"I think this is something way out of mainstream medicine," says Yaron S. Rabinowitz, a clinical professor of ophthalmology at U.C.L.A. School of Medicine. "I just don't think the average ophthalmologist is going to offer something like this in their medical practices."
Rabinowitz further cautions, "While I have no experience with this, it would appear to me that the main potential risks are infection, allergy, erosion of the jewelry and possible loss of the jewelry if you rubbed the eye on a regular basis."
Susan Taub, M.D., assistant professor of ophthalmology at Northwestern University in Chicago, says the three risks of implanting jewels in the mucus membrane of the eye are rejection, infection, and inflammation.
"For anything foreign that is planted in the body you have to worry about these three things," says Taub. "And people doing it for a cosmetic reason should definitely know what the potential complications may be."
Yet with only 50 eyeball jewelry procedures conducted in the world, no one knows what, if any, the long-term risks might be.
Randall Olson, director of the John A. Moran Eye Center at the University of Utah in Salt Lake City, thinks it is too soon to know if the procedure is safe.
"If sterile, [the procedure] will work short term, but dislocation [of the jewel] with exposure and infection is a real possibility," warns Olson. "This all begs the question of why put an eye at risk?"
But Maloney notes that eyeball jewelry can ultimately be removed, if the wearer wants.
"The reality is that if you do get bored with it, unlike a tattoo, you can take it out and throw it away — it can be surgically removed," says Maloney. "If you like the idea of a tattoo but you are little concerned about its permanency, you may want to think about an eye jewel."
For the fashonistas who want JewelEye, H. Dwight Cavanagh, professor and vice chairman, Department of Ophthalmology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas has this advice: "Go only to licensed surgeon-ophthalmologist and understand that follow-up is required."
But remember, as one ophthalmologist said, we only have two eyes. "When it comes to a cosmetic surgery, I think personally that the benefits do not outweigh the risks," says Rutzen.