Democratic wave upends battle over Ten Commandments in Texas classrooms

Critics hope for lax enforcement as legal battles reach the Supreme Court.

HOUSTON -- When Texas lawmakers last year mandated that the Ten Commandments be prominently posted in every classroom of every public school, Rebecca Smith Nash got to work raising money to print thousands of posters of the biblical text and assembling dozens of volunteers to deliver them.

"We know that we have God on our side. So, we put on our armor," said Nash, a mother of two and devout Christian, of the campaign that has sharply divided the Lone Star State.

After years of momentum, winning enactment of classroom mandates in 4 states and inspiring more than a dozen others to consider similar laws, advocates of the Ten Commandments displays now say their success could hang in the balance.

Sweeping Democratic victories in the midterm election -- from statehouses to state legislatures to full control of Congress -- signal a sea change in political priorities, for now.

"The pendulum has swung," said Martin Siegel, a constitutional law scholar and First Amendment expert at the South Texas College of Law.

"The cultural and religious conservative wing of the Republican Party pushed its advantage pretty far, maybe to the outer reaches of what the public will support," Siegel said. "I don't think we're going to see a lot more attempts to infuse religion into school curriculum now that we have a divided legislature and a Democratic governor."

Texas' governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has not yet said how she will handle enforcement of the law or public calls to attempt its repeal, but as a Democratic state legislator she was strongly opposed.

Incoming Texas Democratic leaders will also need to address multiple ongoing legal challenges to the state law and decide whether to continue defending it in court. Under Republican Texas Governor Greg Abbott, the state vigorously defended the Ten Commandments law -- known as SB10 -- against all lawsuits.

The dispute over the Commandments has already reached the U.S. Supreme Court, where the justices are expected to decide in the coming weeks whether to take up the case and decide it next year.

"The Ten Commandments help shape the legal and moral foundations of our nation, and you know, the ideas of respect and truthfulness and responsibility -- these are all essential to a free society," said Jonathan Covey, policy director for Texas Values, a conservative advocacy group that has championed the classroom displays. "Students really deserve to understand about that heritage."

Emily Roth, a Houston mother of two elementary school children who is suing the state over the Commandments, says she shares respect for the biblical values but that it is her right as a parent to present those concepts to her kids.

"We are not able to now introduce faith and religion and Christianity in ways that we want and ways that we control," Roth said. "I'm no longer in control of bringing religion into my child's life because the state is leading it. The state doesn't own my child. My child is mine."

Audrey Nath, a mother of two who has joined Roth in the Texas lawsuit, says she also objects to the concepts presented in the Commandments as inappropriate for elementary school.

"The not coveting thy neighbor's manservant -- that means slave. And I don't think it's okay to say, yeah, sure, don't covet your neighbor's slave," Nash said. "No, if your neighbor is a slave, you should help them escape. None of that is okay for me and what I teach my children."

"The law is still on the books and the poster is still up," she said of the change in state political leadership. "So we're gonna keep fighting until it's gone."

Outside of Texas, the displays may be on firmer footing.

In Louisiana, Alabama, and Arkansas, Republicans retained control of state legislatures and governorships in last month's election, meaning no immediate change is expected in how their respective Ten Commandments mandates are enforced.

New Orleans public school teacher Chris Dier, who was awarded Louisiana teacher of the year in 2020 and opposes posting the biblical imperatives in his classroom, says it will likely take a federal court ruling to get states to back down.

Dier's lawsuit against Louisiana is now pending consideration by the U.S. Supreme Court.

"The fight against having the Ten Commandments in the classroom is not a fight against Christianity itself," said Dier, who identifies as Christian. "We want to make sure we are very clear that we respect all religions."

"I firmly believe it is time for the Supreme Court to step in and make a ruling," he said.

In a landmark decision 46 years ago, the high court struck down a near-identical Kentucky law that had mandated Ten Commandments displays in classrooms, concluding it was a violation of the First Amendment's Establishment Clause, which prohibits government promotion of a particular faith.

That precedent -- Stone v. Graham from 1980 -- may be revisited if the justices agree to take up the Louisiana or Texas cases.

"I think this is the most important First Amendment issue the court has considered really in this century. We're talking millions of kids, millions of families," said Siegel. A decision from the court on whether to wade into the dispute is expected by early next year.

Meanwhile, families in Texas on opposing ends of the political spectrum and Ten Commandments debate are holding firm to their principles.

"I hope that taking the Ten Commandments down off the walls is not a top priority for the Democrats as they come in and take office," said Smith Nash. "If they were to remove it, I would probably stand up and speak out, because it's almost ... I don't know, almost kind of hateful."