Ashe vs. Margolis in Download Fight

Sept. 8, 2000 -- It hasn’t escalated to the level of a Celebrity Deathmatch yet, but two of the Internet’s most downloaded women are sparring over who’s really the cyber-fairest of them all.

Danni Ashe, a nude model and founder of adult Web site “Danni’s Hard Drive,” was crowned by the Guinness Book of World Records as the “Most Downloaded Woman” in the world, dethroning Playboy actress, supermodel and now late-night show host Cindy Margolis.

“I knew all along I had more Internet fans than Cindy, but I was busy running my business and didn’t pay much attention to the hoopla,” gloated Ashe in a statement after the Guinness announcement.

But wait. Who really won — Danni, who’s willing to bear it all, or Cindy, who makes sure she keeps her skimpy bikini on?

A Two-Way Win

Guinness first bestowed the title on Margolis, who then touted it on her Web site. But then, the fickle record-keepers turned it over to Ashe after seeing research and data presented by Ashe — who obviously wasn’t too busy to notice — and Alexa Research of San Francisco, a company that tracks page views and Web site popularity ratings.

This turnabout, of course, started a cat fight between the two babelicious blondes.

“My initial reaction was skepticism that a respected, family publication like the Guinness Book of World Records would associate themselves with the Pornography [sic] industry,” said Margolis in an e-mail to ABCNEWS.com. “I now understand [Guinness’s] obligations, however it does not change my position that I am not, nor do I wish to begin comparing myself or competing with women or Web sites that charge fees to view nudity.

“With loyal Cyberbuddies from 8 to 80, I am and will continue to be a PG girl all the way!” she continued.

But now it appears there may be a happy ending for each. Guinness spokesman Neil Hayes says both of the buxom beauties won, but in different categories.

“In creating two new categories in the ‘most downloaded’ area, we aresimply responding to the different ways in which new media hasdeveloped,” he said in an e-mail statement.

“In this instance, a number of issues were raised by competing claims and the comparisons between them. Most of them focused on the fact there are two inherently different kinds of Web site: subscription-based [and] free sites.”

With this distinction, Guinness will honor both of the women: Ashe will keep her title in the pay-for-view site category, and Margolis will win the title for the most downloads on a free site.

Hayes said Guinness has made distinctions as such in the past. For example, he said, it has “employed similar distinctions between attendance records for free and paid-for concerts, and for print runs of free and paid-for books. All we are doing in this instance is taking our existing criteria into a new medium.”

According to Guinness numbers, Ashe had more than 240 million downloads in 1999 from Danni’s Hard Drive, a subscription site. Margolis’ people recorded 53 million downloads using the numbers she racked up based on America Online downloads alone. (Margolis’s agents plan to resubmit additional calculations, according to Hayes.)

Ashe, however, maintains the numbers support her claim to the crown“I have more [downloads] no matter how you want to add it up,” she said in a telephone interview.

Millions and Millions Served

As far as Web traffic goes, Margolis’ site, Cindymargolis.com, trailed Danni’s Hard Drive by a significant margin, according to Alexa Research numbers. Cindymargolis.com boasted a little more than 2 million page views in May of 2000, vs. well over 25 million page views during the same month on Ashe’s site.

Ashe, who says she’s content with her new title, wants to be more than just the most heavily trafficked pay-for Web site. She wants to hold both records, saying that even on her free-downloads site, she got more than 120 million downloads in this past year, and around the same number on her pay-per-download site.

“The thing that really interests me is that Cindy’s numbers, the ones that have been submitted thus far, came from AOL,” Ashe said.

Margolis, however, makes the case that what Ashe does, and what she, or any subscription-based Web site does is of “an inherently different character.”

“[And] In case you are not aware, Yahoo Internet Life Magazine makes no allowance for pornographic and/or subscription based Web sites when considering the ‘Most Downloaded Woman’ award in their annual Top of the Net Issue,” Margolis said regarding the honor she received from them in 1999 and 2000.

“[And] that’s a paid subscription service too.”

“I think that Cindy’s career is really kind of based on this title,” said Ashe. “And it’s difficult for her to lose it. Right now she’s still got it, but not for much longer.”