Court Overturns Injunction in Amazon Patent Case

S E A T T L E, Feb. 15, 2001 -- A federal appeals court overturned a lower courtruling that barred bookseller Barnes and Noble's Internet storefrom using Amazon.com’s single-click checkout technology, pending atrial.

Amazon.com of Seattle has argued that New York-based Barnes andNoble uses technology that is too similar to Amazon’s patented“1-Click” system. Amazon sued Barnes and Noble in October 1999for patent infringement.

Amazon’s system stores billing and shipping information soonline customers don’t have to re-enter the data each time theybuy. Theoretically, someone can buy a product with just one mouseclick. Barnes and Noble’s online subsidiary, barnesandnoble.com,uses a similar system, called Express Lane.

After the first step of the trial, in December 1999, U.S.District Judge Marsha J. Pechman issued the preliminary injunction,which Barnes and Noble appealed. The full patent infringement caseis not scheduled to be heard in District Court until thisSeptember.

Patently Clear?

In its ruling Wednesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for theFederal Circuit in Washington, D.C., said it believed Barnes andNoble “has mounted a substantial challenge to the validity of thepatent.” Based on that, the court said it did not believe Amazonwas entitled to preliminary injunction relief.

Barnes and Noble said the ruling validates its argument that thecase is without merit.

“We had said throughout this case that we do not intend to sitback and allow Amazon.com to stake claim upon any technology thatis widely used,” the company said.

Amazon said the ruling does not address the validity of thepatent-infringement suit. Amazon spokeswoman Patty Smith saidAmazon is preparing to go to trial.

Both companies declined to comment further on the case.

Greg Aharonian, editor of the Internet Patent News Service andan expert in technology patents, said the case is more important asa barometer of Internet law than for what it will mean for Barnesand Noble.

After the injunction, he said, Barnes and Noble simply tweakedits technology to avoid what might have been seen as patentinfringement and continued to sell products in a similar way. But,he said, the case may prove to be a barometer for how softwarepatents are handled.

“This is not about Amazon but about everyone,” he said.

Shares of barnesandnoble.com fell 9 cents to $1.75 on the NasdaqStock Market. Amazon shares were up 68 cents to $14.44.