Probation in Suicide Van Case
Man who suspected his wife was suicidal watched her drive the kids off a cliff.
June 6, 2007 -- After his wife drove their children off a 300-foot cliff at Bear Mountain last summer, Victor Han told police he knew his wife had been suicidal. He just didn't know she would take their children with her.
Today, in a Rockland County court, Han will receive a sentence of probation, prosecutors told ABC News' Law & Justice Unit.
The couple's two children, then 3 and 5, did not sustain permanent injuries, but Victor Han' wife, Heijn Han, died at the scene of internal injuries and a broken spine. Victor Han recounted the harrowing episode in a statement to police last year. He told police his wife was sometimes suicidal, and that she may have been upset about an affair he was having with a 31-year-old work colleague.
As part of plea deal -- which ensures that the 35-year-old, self-employed architect will not retain custody of his two daughters -- he will be sentenced to three years' probation this morning in Rockland County court in New York, prosecutors there told ABC News.
"You're talking about a case where you have to decide what was the operation of not only [Victor Han's] mind but his wife's mind as well,'' Rockland County Chief Assistant District Attorney Louis Valvo told ABC News.
In a statement to police after the incident, Han said he didn't realize his wife's intention to drive off the cliff with the children in the car until it was too late.
"He thought she was going to jump off a cliff," Valvo said. "He never thought she was going to take the kids with her. That's one of the problems with this case. You have to microscopically determine what Victor Han and his wife were both thinking."
Valvo said that New York state defines felony depraved reckless indifference as taking an action "under circumstances evincing a depraved indifference to human life, which creates a grave risk'' to another person.
"But here in the New York, the courts are divided on what the standards of evidence are to reach that bar,'' Valvo said. "How much did he know about his wife's thoughts that day? He and the two kids are the only witnesses we had."
Most Serious Charges Dropped
In March, Rockland County District Attorney Michael Bongiorno dropped the most serious felony charges of promoting suicide and reckless endangerment and allowed Han to plead guilty to misdemeanor child endangerment. Had Han gone to trial and lost, he would have faced between 28 months and seven years in prison. Bongiorno told reporters after the plea deal that it was his first time in 12 years as a district attorney that he'd brought a charge of promoting suicide.
Han reportedly muttered "yes" in court to questions from prosecutors detailing his thoughts and actions that day. He admitted he knew his wife and children were in danger when he stepped out of the car at the cliff side that day, because he knew his wife was suicidal. He had previously told New York State Park Police after the incident that his wife may have been upset over his extramarital affair.
"In the end I think it was an appropriate disposition, given the unique situation in this case,'' Valvo said.
Friends and relatives from the South Korean community in Queens, N.Y., where Han and his wife taught Sunday school Bible classes together at the Korean Presbyterian Church, had reportedly been present at most of Han's court appearances, but that day Han stood alone before the judge.
"There was a certain amount of shame,'' defense attorney Lawrence Goldman told The Associated Press. Goldman did not return calls from ABC News for comment on the probation sentence Tuesday.
In April, Han acknowledged that FBI computer technicians had discovered pornography involving children on his home computer. He told the Staten Island Advance that he believed the photo files were temporary files from his hard drive that were the result of "pop up'' ads. No charges have been brought to date in relation to that investigation.
Dark Day
In a statement made to police a week after the June 14, 2006, tragedy, Han described a depressing day for the head of a family.
It began when Han dropped off his wife and daughter Ariana that June morning at Ariana's preschool graduation. He said he took his other daughter, Etana, to "buy CDs and chocolate'' at a local Duane Reade drugstore. He returned from the store to find a parking ticket on his Honda Odyssey minivan.
After lunch, his wife suggested the family drive to Bear Mountain, about 50 miles north of New York City. Han may have thought that request odd, as he had previously told his wife of a fantasy of ending his own life at Bear Mountain
Han told police that earlier that year, he wrote a distraught note to his wife telling her he felt shameful that he'd let his family down because all he could afford for his daughter Etana's birthday that year was some takeout Chinese food.
"I felt like I let them down,'' he told police in a written statement.
That February, he wrote, "I took the family to Bear Mountain.''
"I was very quiet on the trip, and when we got home, I wrote a note to [his wife] Heijn stating that I had let everybody down and that the real reason that I wanted to go to Bear Mountain was to jump. I then left the house for two days. I went to my office, drank and went to a hotel.''
"Uneasy Feeling"
So when his wife suggested after the June graduation that the family head back to Bear Mountain, "I began to get an uneasy feeling about what was going on,'' Han wrote.
"As we passed through the [park] gate from Seven Lakes Drive up to the tower, Heijn said 'How about here?' [referring to a scenic overlook]. I stopped and we looked around and then continued. Up a little farther, she said it again. We stopped, looked around and continued."
Han said he began to worry "because Heijn was depressed."
"As we got to the top, Heijn said 'Let's take the hiking trail.' At this time I became scared of what she was thinking. She was upset and quiet. I believe she was wanting to kill herself."
His thoughts were apparently interrupted by his wife.
'"We can't leave without taking at least one photo,'' she told him, Han told police. They circled back up to a tower on a cliff, and Han said he took the camera and got out of the van.
"I turned around, and I faced the car,'' he wrote in the statement. "I saw Heijn in the middle of the car, and the car was going. The car was turned and going toward the cliff. I hesitated and then reacted when I saw Etana. I ran to the car and screamed, 'Stop the car, stop the car.' I tried grabbing at the car but could not grab anything"
Heijn Han, with her two daughters buckled into the back seat, steered the car through a 14-foot-wide opening between two boulders, and went over the cliff.
"I see the car go down rolling, and I hear screams. It stops, and I see a puff of smoke. I called 911 …"
Han said he ran down the side of the mountain in a fit of terror.
"I was on the phone for about 30 seconds. I could not give them a location, so I stopped talking and went to help Ariana. I went straight to her and asked if she was OK. She said Etana was bleeding. I got her out of the car and was checking on them. I went to get Heijn out, but the door was locked. I broke the window with a rock and unlocked the door. I saw Heijn and froze. She was bloody and has stuff coming out of her nose."
He first tried again to get his wife out of the car but failed, falling down in the process. So he said he left a bystander with his family and ran to get help.
Rockland County prosecutors told ABC News that Han's children are being cared for by his wife's sister. By order of a New York family court, he is allowed limited, supervised visits for the length of his three to five years' parole.