Missed Opportunities Haunt Smart Case

March 14, 2003 -- Elizabeth Smart is back with her family after nine months as a kidnap victim, but alleged blunders in the investigation still haunt Salt Lake City police.

The Smart family publicly harbors no ill will toward police for not focusing more intensely and earlier on Brian David Mitchell, the homeless drifter and former Smart handyman who calls himself Emmanuel and is now in custody for allegedly kidnapping Elizabeth. But there may have been missed opportunities to previously rescue the 15-year-old girl.

According to today's edition of The Salt Lake Tribune, Mitchell was arrested Sept. 27 in Salt Lake City for shoplifting. Citing court records, the paper reported that he allegedly told police his name was "Immanuel" and "Lueal" and skipped a court appearance. Mitchell pleaded not guilty to the shoplifting charges during a court hearing today.

In addition, officials at the San Diego Sheriff's Department say they arrested Mitchell on Feb. 12 for vandalizing a church and that he was in custody for six days. He pleaded guilty to the charge and was released.

At the time, officials said, Mitchell was not using the Emmanuel alias and was using another name. They were unaware that Salt Lake police wanted him for questioning at the time.

Two days before Mitchell's arrest in San Diego, the Smart family released sketches of "Emmanuel" and appealed for the public's help in finding him. They did not know the suspect's full name at the time but said Mary Katherine, Elizabeth's 10-year-old sister and the sole eyewitness to her abduction, told them the kidnapper looked something like the former handyman.

Mary Katherine told her family about the Emmanuel connection back in October. Salt Lake City police said the family first told them about Emmanuel on Oct. 13 and then interviewed Mary Katherine two days later. Between October and early February, half of the investigators were devoted to following unexplained questions regarding the original top suspect in kidnapping, Richard Ricci, and searching for Emmanuel.

Salt Lake City Mayor Rocky Anderson said today that an independent panel will be named to investigate how police carried out the investigation. The mayor said he decided to order the investigation not because he believes police mishandled the case, but to answer the question being raised by the public and the media, and to help police handle investigations better in the future if there were any mistakes.

Hindsight Is 20/20

Three different composite sketches were made of Mitchell, Salt Lake City police Chief Rick Dinse said. The Smart family wanted to go public with one of the sketches early on, but the task force was against that idea because they did not feel like they had an accurate composite and did not want to generate an influx of futile leads.

On Feb. 10, the family wanted to go public with a sketch and the investigators gave them their blessing. That public showing of the sketch led to Mitchell's sister calling authorities with his identity and the man's stepson providing investigators with photos ultimately led to Elizabeth's rescue. Salt Lake City police conceded they may have made some mistakes.

"In hindsight, it's 20/20 vision," Dinse said during a Thursday evening press conference. "If we had to go back over it again that decision by the investigators. I think every and each one of them would say I wish we had gone public with that photograph sooner."

Dinse said Salt Lake police did not issue a multi-state bulletin for Mitchell because he did not have a violent criminal background and they did not have enough evidence to consider him a suspect. Still, the Smarts said they do not think police botched search for Elizabeth.

"We in no way want to impugn anybody," said Tom Smart, one of Elizabeth's uncles. "I mean I think I've probably made a mistake or two in the last nine months. … We are so grateful to everybody in law enforcement who's worked on this."

Brainwashing and Polygamy Questions

Mitchell, 49, and his wife, Wanda Barzee, 57, are in custody awaiting possible state and federal kidnapping charges. Salt Lake City prosecutors are expected to file aggravating kidnapping charges against Mitchell Monday.

Elizabeth was found Wednesday in Sandy City, Utah — about 15 miles from her home — with Mitchell and Barzee after two women called police separately after they and their husbands recognized Mitchell as resembling the sketch and photos they had seen on television of "Emmanuel."

The motive for the alleged kidnapping remains unclear.

Police said the investigation is active and there may be more arrests of people who may have known who Elizabeth was but did not come forward.

Ed Smart, Elizabeth's father, told ABCNEWS' Good Morning America Thursday that he believes Mitchell had brainwashed his daughter to keep her from trying to leave him or contact police during the nine months he kept her.

"I can tell he did an absolute brainwashing on her," said Smart, who had worked tirelessly to make sure police and the media did not slacken their attention to his daughter's case. "It's going to be difficult and it's going to be a long road but she's a strong girl and I know she's going to make it."

The Smarts had hired Mitchell to help them with work around their home, and Ed Smart said he never would have suspected "such an animal" lived in his former handyman. In a press conference Thursday evening, Dinse only said Elizabeth's captors had "psychologically impacted" her, but the police chief would not further elaborate.

Responding to reports over whether Mitchell had taken Elizabeth to be his wife, Dinse would only say, "His religious belief was in polygamy." Dinse did not want to characterize Elizabeth's relationship with Mitchell as husband and wife or wife-to-be.

Hidden Practically in the Family’s Back Yard

Police say Elizabeth has told them her captors held her against her will at a camp site in the mountains behind the Smart home in the first two months after her abduction. They then made her wear a wig, a full robe and veil.

Elizabeth, Mitchell and Barzee then lived in a Salt Lake City apartment that is only two blocks away from a police station and in October, traveled to California, where police believe they moved from camp site to camp site in San Diego. Between October and Elizabeth's recovery, police believe the trio may have traveled through California and Nevada before returning to Utah at around 3 a.m. Wednesday.

Police said they are still exploring a number a leads and were investigating information that Elizabeth was also taken to Florida and Georgia.

Elizabeth, then 14, was kidnapped early June 5, 2002, by a man who apparently entered the the Smart house by cutting a window screen near the back door. She was taken from the bedroom she shared with Mary Katherine, then 9, who pretended to be asleep.

The younger girl told authorities she heard the man threaten to hurt Elizabeth if the teen didn't keep quiet. Mary Katherine also said she thought the intruder had a gun, but it was later revealed he allegedly had a knife.

ABCNEWS' Bill Redeker contributed to this report.