Judge Affirms Waco Jury Finding
D A L L A S, Sept. 20, 2000 -- A federal judge today absolved the government of blame in the deaths of some 80Branch Davidians in the 1993 Waco siege and fire, issuing afinal verdict dismissing a lawsuit brought by survivors andrelatives of the dead.
U.S. District Judge Walter Smith upheld the July findingsof an advisory jury that federal agents were not responsiblefor a 51-day armed standoff at the Davidian compound in centralTexas or for a blaze that consumed the building after an FBItank and tear-gas assault.
The judge also dismissed a motion by Davidian lawyers toforce him to recuse himself from the case and called theirallegations that he was biased “either false or made withreckless disregard as to their truth or falsity.”
The five-member advisory jury’s finding was not bindingunder federal rules for civil lawsuits against the U.S.government. Instead, the judge was empowered to reach a finalverdict based on the jury’s decision and the evidence in a3-1/2-week trial.
It was the latest defeat for Davidians in a seven-yearbattle with the U.S. government over responsibility for theWaco siege. Shortly after the advisory jury’s July verdict, aspecial investigator named by the Justice Department exoneratedAttorney General Janet Reno and the U.S. government of anyblame.