Jennings Interviews Home Security Chief Ridge

W A S H I N G T O N, Jan. 29, 2002 -- Hours before President Bush's first State of the Union address, ABCNEWS' Peter Jennings interviewed Tom Ridge, the director of homeland security. Following is a transcript of the interview.

PETER JENNINGS, ABCNEWS: Has the overall threat to the country diminished since September?

TOM RIDGE, DIRECTOR OF HOMELAND SECURITY: I don't think so. I think the involvement of the military and the interdiction of some of the financing has probably made potential operations more difficult, but from my vantage point and in my office, we work as if the threat is maintained at the same level as it was on 9/11.

JENNINGS: You do that from an operational basis. In other words, it keeps you sharp to operate as if the threat has not diminished.

RIDGE: Uh-huh.

JENNINGS: But would you say that in real terms it has?

RIDGE: No, I would say that in real terms the threat remains at the same level. We get communications. There's an intelligence briefing every day. And when the president reminds America to be on the alert, to be vigilant — I had to step out one day and do that as well — it is simply because, although we've disrupted their military activity and some operational planning, we still think we have to maintain the same level of vigilance for the foreseeable future.

JENNINGS: The country's coming up on two very big national events and international in one case, the Olympics … in Salt Lake City, and the Super Bowl this weekend. Is it safe to go to the Super Bowl this weekend?

RIDGE: Yes. It's safe to go to the Super Bowl and it's safe to go to the Olympics. Both are designated as special security events. The Secret Service has been working both operations for quite some time, over two years out in Salt Lake City. Obviously, there's no guarantee that it's fail safe, but there is the work, collaboration, and coordination of the federal, the state and local government, a variety of the federal, state and local agencies. It's as safe as humanly and technologically possible.

JENNINGS: If I'm not mistaken, this is the first time the Secret Service has been involved in a Super Bowl. What message should we take from that?

RIDGE: Well, actually, the responsibility or the opportunity for the Secret Service to get involved as a planning agent really wasn't available to too many Super Bowls in the past. This is the first one, but given the 9/11, the tragedy of that day, and the ongoing threat that we feel still exists, it was deemed appropriate to designate this as a special event.

'Unpredictable Nature of Terrorists'

JENNINGS: Would you be surprised, Governor, if terrorists attack at the Super Bowl or the Olympics; would you be surprised?

RIDGE: I wouldn't be surprised if they tried. I don't think they will. I think we're ready, and it is a — that is the nature of terrorism that gives the president and everybody in the Cabinet and everyone in our office the greatest sense of concern, is the unpredictable nature of terrorists, their act, their striking out at innocent civilians. And I wouldn't be surprised. And it's still a possibility.

JENNINGS: I was actually struck by your hesitation, because it really is, is it not, something to think about all the time as to whether or not if terrorists struck in the country again, you of all people would be surprised.

RIDGE: I think I have to deal with that. The staff deals with it. The president deals with it. We do everything we can in terms of planning and preparation, but we were surprised on 9/11, we were surprised in '93 when they hit the World Trade Center, we were surprised when they hit industries overseas. I'm not sure we should be surprised in the sense any longer that we are a target, because we feel that [Osama] bin Laden, al Qaeda and the follow-on to bin Laden and al Qaeda will always look to bring their form of devastation, and war, and destruction to this country. That's why certain events are designated special security events because of their heightened visibility, the worldwide attention that's given to them.

It's something that I wrestle with every single hour of every single day, is that unpredictable nature of terrorism that gives us all great concern.

JENNINGS: The thing about terrorism is it is so surprising when it occurs. So you have two venues, as you put it, the Super Bowl and the Olympics. In some respects it's the last place I feel you expect terrorists to attack.

RIDGE: Well, I'm sure they gain a lot of information about us. We are a free and open society. We're an information society … And they know the kind of security precautions we're taking.

So you do everything you can to reduce the possibility of surprise. You do everything you can to prepare for the event, both from the intelligence-gathering point of view to being able to respond to an incident if it occurs. But I think as a permanent condition in the 21st century, it's the responsibility of our office to do the best we can to ensure that these events — and that America generally has an infrastructure to deal with, first, the responsibility to try to impede, prevent, and deter the attack, and then, God forbid something happens, to be able to respond to it as quickly as humanly possible.

Safer Since He Started?

JENNINGS: So tell us what's changed since you got here.

RIDGE: A great deal has changed, Peter. I think every day since 9/11 I think America has gotten safer and safer. I've said many, many times that I wish all Americans could sit in my office with me — you and I just have a few moments together. But if everybody could sit with me for about a week and have the conversations that I have with other Americans, both in government and the private sector, look at some of the innovation, the technology, talk to how emergency responders are working, talk to my counterparts in the 50 states and the territories, talk to the private sector in terms of what they've done since 9/11, I think they would be convinced and reassured that every day since 9/11 America has become a safer place, but we still have some distance travel.

But the beauty of the opportunity I have to serve this country and this president — the president has given me the opportunity not only to look at ways to make America more secure, but at the same time look for ways to make us better and stronger.

JENNINGS: So how does it work? I mean, I accept that you believe it has changed since you got here. But how has it changed and how does it work? How do we know, we average guys, that it is safer?

RIDGE: Well, I think there are visible signs of safety. I mean, you're going to see — we see visible signs of safety in our airports. You're going to see visible signs at the meetings we talked about. There's changes in our public health infrastructure.

So as we've developed a national plan, a homeland security strategy, the first fingerprints were around the budget that is going to help our first responders, our policemen and our firemen and our emergency medical personnel, you're going to see that. There's going to be more training. There's going to be more equipment. There are going to be more exercises. You're going to see some changes in how we prepare for another bioterrorism incident. You're going to see an increase in epidemiologists. You're going to see an enhancement of the public health infrastructure. You're going to see coordination with local law enforcement, emergency medical folks, and the doctors. You're going to see more coordination around — around this country.

But at the same time, there will be a lot of things that you won't see. There will be some changes in the relationships between the agencies and information sharing. You're not going to see the collaboration between the federal law enforcement community and the state and local law enforcement community. You're not going to see all the technology that's being put into place. And there will be, again, some visible signs of this effort and a lot of things that Americans won't see, but they should feel very confident that both the private sector, individuals, companies, and the government are making changes every day.

JENNINGS: Or at least you'd like us to feel confident.

RIDGE: Well, I hope you would feel more comfortable and confident that since 9/11, one, you should legitimately expect since 9/11 the government, all those levels of government have moved forward to make you more secure. That's a legitimate expectation.

What Went Wrong?

JENNINGS: But help us understand this. Why was what the country had before, the FBI, the Justice Department in general, the Treasury Department, the CIA, why was that not adequate? What was wrong?

RIDGE: I don't think there was anything wrong. I just don't believe that the threat of non-state terrorism had been elevated in the minds of all levels of government or the private sector so that it became a priority, a priority for research, a priority for investment, a priority for human resources.

After 9/11, when the threat of non-state — we've always been prepared for a battle with a foreign government, a foreign sovereign. But the notion — I think we felt somewhat immune. We've got friendly borders to the North and South. We've got big oceans and an expanse of water between ourselves and the rest of the world. We saw political terrorism in other parts of the world, the Middle East, U.K., Germany, and Italy. And somehow I think we felt that we were immune from that. And I think the global tragedy of 9/11 and the subsequent anthrax crimes made us aware in a very real and very painful way that this is part of our 21st century world.

JENNINGS: I realize this is also a question about incremental change, because everyone agrees that the country needs better security.

RIDGE: Right.

JENNINGS: The question is how badly do you think the country needs it at the moment.

RIDGE: Well, the term "badly" suggests that we didn't have any procedures or resources in place prior to 9/11, and that's not true. But what has — what has happened is that — from government's perspective is that the work of the INS, the work of Customs, the work of the Coast Guard, the work of the Department of Defense, the intelligence-gathering agencies, generally while focused on terrorism, have suddenly been expanded. There's a real-world need for it to expand. And while they were prepared — one is prepared, as we know now, the reality of the 21st century world requires us to be prepared.

And I'm not sure we're ever going to get to the point where we can say we're finished, the task is done, we are as prepared as we can possibly be, because it's not a static situation. I mean, as we learn more about our enemies, as we learn more about those who would undermine our way of life, I think we have to be prepared to adjust and respond. The budget, the president in the State of the Union talks a little bit about tonight, shows some very significant first steps in that preparation, but it has to be a multi-year plan, and it has to be a dynamic plan. We have to be flexible, be able to respond.

Bush's Priority: Homeland Security

JENNINGS: I think everyone agrees that it makes sense from the president's point of view to have one man, and his man, to oversee this. But you know that all the talk in this Capital and in other places is about Tom Ridge's authority. How anxious do you feel that you don't have independent authority?

RIDGE: The president has made it his number one priority. Everybody knows it. I've got his support. I've got his ear. That's all the authority I need.

JENNINGS: It will come as no surprise to you that I brought the famous organizational chart with me, not so much — not so much for to surprise you because it is no surprise. You've seen this as well.

This is you right up here under the president. Has this changed since you got here? And if it hasn't changed, my tendency, any reporter's tendency is to say, come on, you've got to be kidding.

RIDGE: That was my first reaction when I saw it as well. I think, technically, the lines are still distributed in the same fashion, but what they do not reflect is the unprecedented level of collaboration among these agencies that I don't think existed before 9/11.

And what it doesn't reflect will be some of the changes that I think will be effected in the months and years ahead. But that shows America that before 9/11 there were literally hundreds of thousands of men and women in the federal government who had some portion of homeland security as part of their professional responsibility, but it also shows that we need to do a lot better job in terms of setting up lines of communication and accountability.

JENNINGS: Because it does look, does it not, it does look like a metaphor for the madness of government.

RIDGE: Well, that, yes, I couldn't have said it better.

Faced Resistance at Consolidating Border Agencies

JENNINGS: As I said, that comes as no surprise to you, but were you surprised at the — at the resistance you got when you tried to consolidate the borderland security agencies? Everybody dug in their heels.

RIDGE: No. Again, I wasn't surprised at that because, having been down here for 12 years as a member of Congress, I can well appreciate that the men and women who now have an agency that has responsibilities at the border feel very, very strongly that, under any and all circumstances, their way is the best way. It's a culture. You think you're doing everything you could, as well as you could, what — so I wasn't surprised at the push-back.

But we have, after that initial discussion, continued discussions with everybody involved.

JENNINGS: That means you're still pushing?

RIDGE: That means we're still discussing the need to determine what are our goals for the borders in the 21st century in lieu of 9/11, in lieu of an entirely different environment, including nonstate terrorism, and do we really think that a 20th-century structure and disparate agencies, it can be as many as 10 or 11, operating independently … and the collaboration, is the best way for us to deal with those borders in the 21st century? Because you're dealing with commerce, you're dealing with terrorism, you're dealing with drug interdiction, you're dealing with illegal immigrants, and the list goes on and on.

So we're looking now at a broad array of alternatives to deal differently, specifically.

JENNINGS: Do you believe that you are right, and these agencies, which control or try to control the borders, must be consolidated under your department?

RIDGE: I believe that some form of integration and some form of consolidation will dramatically improve our ability to reach our goals, and there are many goals dealing with the borders, what form of consolidation remains to be seen. One of the first things we're going to try to do is develop a consensus on goals, objectives, and then pull back from that and say, look, do we really think the way we used to conduct business at the borders is the best way to conduct borders in the 21st century? Time will tell.

Working Toward Mutual Goals

JENNINGS: I totally appreciate your diplomacy. But how much of a serious problem is territorial imperative? One department has always done it. One department believes it does it right. One department wants to keep it in its pocket. How are you, Tom Ridge, going to change that?

RIDGE: First, by consensus building. And if I step back and took a look at that process, we probably should have spent a little bit more time talking with the principals about our mutual goals.

I feel very, very strongly that there needs to be significant reorganization at the borders. It may start and begin with a technology overlay, and shared information, and shared resources, but it's coming to — it's finally coming to the surface that we don't even have an entry and exit monitoring system in this country with regard to visas — whether or not you need multiple agencies dealing with that or one agency dealing with that.

So I think we're going to have a technology overlay, and at some point in time, I feel very strongly about it — we [inaudible] bring some of these agencies together.

There's no real accountability for conduct at the borders. Customs has responsibilities in certain areas INS has responsibilities in certain areas. Coast Guard has responsibilities in certain areas. And so in terms of accountability, I think it's very, very important to get things done. It's somewhat diffused in government. And I think it's in our long-term best interest to bring them back together.

JENNINGS: Again, you're being diplomatic. One could argue, Governor, that just the U.S.-Canadian border, which is often described as the longest undefended border in the world, is a mess.

RIDGE: Well, I would probably disagree with that because of the work that has happened even prior to 9/11. Secretary O'Neill was up there and Attorney General Ashcroft was up there. But since my visit with then the Foreign Minister and now the Deputy Prime Minister, John Manley, we are working very, very hard and very aggressively on a border accord that we have smart borders, and, again, at the president's direction. Let's look at the borders and make sure they're more secure, but let's at the same time make sure they're better and we can facilitate commerce, the flow of goods and services across the borders. And I think we've made a great deal of progress and that you're going to see accelerated progress in the months ahead.

Price to the Taxpayer

JENNINGS: The president in the State of the Union address will say that he wants $38 billion this year.

RIDGE: Nearly double the 2002 budget.

JENNINGS: For additional security.

RIDGE: Correct.

JENNINGS: What's the taxpayer going to get?

RIDGE: The taxpayer will get a dramatically enhanced public-health infrastructure. It's one thing to deal with the threat of a bioterrorist event; it's another thing to say, well, we want to prepare ourselves to do that.

But at the same time, let us enhance the public-health system as well — because it has been degraded from lack of attention and support for the past ten years — so again we are more secure and better. So you're going to see more investment in the public health infrastructure, greater investment in INS and Customs and Coast Guard, giving them more capacity to deal with their traditional missions, as well as the new mission of trying to prevent terrorism.

You're going to see $3.5 billion going to first responders — the policemen, the firemen, the emergency medical personnel. It's going to go for equipment and training and underwriting exercises so we can plan and prepare. So there will be some visible manifestation that the taxpayer can look to. Hopefully the taxpayer will be able to respond.

These are good investments in America because they will make us more secure; but if we enhance the ability of the policemen and the firemen, it will be a safer community. It's a good investment in public health, not only because it helps us deal with potential terrorist attacks, but we need a stronger public health structure. It's a good investment in technology not only because it makes us more secure, it'll enhance the quality of life in other ways. So they're better, stronger and safer.

'First Responders'

JENNINGS: I am struck, and I think other people are as well, at how often in this one conversation alone you mentioned "first responders." The resumption is that the terrorists are going to get through.

RIDGE: Well, the reason we mention first responders is, quite candidly, their heroism, their courage, their sacrifice that everyone noticed on September 11th and has been talking about and trying to deal with since that tragedy … And it is apparent that as they dealt with that incident, that the country needed a little more assistance in that regard as well.

JENNINGS: The presumption is the terrorists are going to get through.

RIDGE: This is just in response to the crisis. But part of the homeland security strategy and the battle is to push the perimeter as far out as we can to prevent and isolate and undo any potential operation. And as we develop that long-term strategy, that's right.

When you deal with crisis or consequence management, you said that the incident has occurred and we have to deal with it. But the other part of the responsibility of the office is at the front end, and that's pushing the perimeter out and making sure it doesn't happen. And to that end, the attorney general and the FBI and a lot of other agencies at the federal level — as well as the state and local level — will be working, have been working on that issue. And it's a very high priority for the president as well.

JENNINGS: I don't want to belabor this point, but are you aware that in so much of your conversation about Homeland Security now, on another public occasions, there is this inherent presumption that terrorists will succeed in attacking the United States again.

RIDGE: Well, I want to disrespectfully disagree with the presumption.

I think as we work on consequence management, it's part of a continual responsibility to the Office of Homeland Security. Obviously, the best protection, the best security, the very best plan, is to make sure that we are able to detect and deter an incident before it occurs, and so the Office of Homeland Security deals with that portion of intelligence gathering and sharing, and the deterrence all the way to consequence management.

The reason that consequence management and the first responders, these brave, heroic, courageous people that we have celebrated more since September 11th than ever before, because we see an immediate need to move to infuse dollars into equipment and training exercises. But that does not mean that we're working that side of the issue alone. Obviously working on the front side as well, prevent, deter. It's the best. Push the perimeter out as far as you can, get it away from the United States.

JENNINGS: It is a huge deal for this president, huge deal for the country, huge deal for Gov. Tom Ridge. Do you worry often (or even on occasion) that the American public will tire or become lax of the constant need, as you remind us, to be on our guard, to be alert, to be looking over our shoulders?

RIDGE: Peter, I think it's human nature. And that the further away we get from September 11 and the anthrax crimes, people will perhaps down the road begin to feel a false sense of security, like it was an aberrant event that's not going to happen again.

But I do believe that as long as we stay as alert and keep our guard up, we will minimize terrorist activity, but we'll never be able to prevent it.

JENNINGS: That's a huge political challenge for you and for a president. Will we be as patient a year from now standing in the lines at the airports as we currently are.

RIDGE: Maybe we can have an interview then. We'll both be able to take a look at how we responded over the past year.

I think one of the things that we're going to do — and I think the president is going to talk about this in his remarks — is how we get America engaged, the individual citizen engaged in this war on terrorism. I mean from the day that my announcement was made that there was going to be an Office of Homeland Security and I'd have the opportunity to lead it, thousands of people have asked, hundreds of thousands of people have written to the president, and their congressmen and their senators, "How can we help?" And I think you're going to see the president lay out some opportunities tonight to get America, the individual citizen, engaged in helping their community, helping their country, and helping their family combat terrorism.

And I think if we get the people engaged, be less inclined to make homeland security an afterthought if we have groups and individuals engaged in protecting America.